Next: Special set hearing · Thu, Dec 17, 10:30 AM
A South Florida landlord claims Starbucks schemed to get out of a lease by exploiting a city work order and then sued him for unsafe conditions.
No comments yet. What do you make of this case?
Updates · 16
The city and some officials are asking the judge to throw out the case. They say they should be protected from being sued (called sovereign immunity) and give other reasons too. A judge will listen to both sides at this hearing.
The judge ordered that the case will go to trial without a jury (the judge decides instead of a jury), and also referred the parties to mediation, where a neutral person helps them try to settle. It also schedules a calendar call on 11-16-2026 at 11:00 AM.
A calendar call is set. This is a short court meeting where the judge checks in with the lawyers about the case schedule and next steps.
The defendants filed a reply supporting their amended motion to dismiss and opposing the plaintiff's response. This is the defendants arguing again that the case should be thrown out.
The plaintiff filed a response arguing why the case should not be thrown out. This is the plaintiff's chance to fight back against the defendants' motion to dismiss.
The defendants filed an updated request to throw the case out with new or changed arguments. This replaces or adds to their earlier motion and is important to whether the case continues.
The judge said no to the plaintiff's request for an early court order. This is a key ruling against the plaintiff on an important request.
The defendants filed a response arguing against the plaintiff's request for an early court order. This shows both sides are fighting hard over the injunction request.
The plaintiff asked the court to rule against the defendants automatically for not responding in time. This is a serious request in the case.
The defendants asked the judge to throw the case out, arguing it should not move forward. This is an important early fight over whether the case survives.
The court set dates for a hearing on the plaintiff's request to make the defendants change their behavior during the case. A hearing means the judge will hear arguments in court.
The court officially notified the defendants that they are being sued by issuing summonses to City of Miami Beach, Richard Clements, Steven Cosner, and A.J. Prieto. This tells the defendants they must respond to the lawsuit.
The plaintiff asked the judge to order the defendants to stop or do something right away while the case is still going on. This is called a preliminary injunction and is a major early request in the case.
The plaintiff officially started the lawsuit by filing a complaint, which is the document that explains the claims against the defendants. The complaint is one of the most important documents in any case.
Alleged in the plaintiff’s complaint:
A water company's majority owner allegedly siphoned funds, inflated fees, and cooked the books, leaving his partner all wet.
Added
Alleged in the plaintiff’s complaint:
A family says a hospital and hospice lost their father's body, then a funeral home showed them a stranger in his place. They're suing for the heartbreak of never getting him back.
Added
Alleged in the plaintiff’s complaint:
An ER doctor with IBS had an accident in the hospital garage. After 15 years, he says he was forced to resign or be fired-and then bad-mouthed to a new employer.
Added
Comments