Commenting guidelines

Last updated: October 30, 2026.

Miami Case Watch is a public reading room for cases. Comments are visible to anyone. These guidelines are a starting point for how to take part. We may update them.

Be civil

Disagree about the case, not the person. Insults, slurs, and pile-ons are not allowed. Critique the filing, the testimony, or the argument.

No harassment or threats

Do not target someone with abuse, sexual harassment, or threats of violence. Do not encourage other people to do that either.

Protect people's privacy

Do not post personal contact details, home addresses, private account information, or anything else that would let a stranger find or harass someone. That includes people involved in a case, witnesses, jurors, and other commenters.

Stay on the case

Keep the comment tied to the case you are reading. Off-topic promotion, repetitive posting, and spam will be removed.

Do not impersonate

Do not present yourself as someone you are not. That includes a username, a display name, or a claim in a message that pretends you are another person, a party to the case, a lawyer, a court, or Miami Case Watch. Impersonation is not allowed. It is a bannable offense under the terms of service.

No illegal or dangerous content

Do not post content that sexualizes anyone under 18, other sexually explicit material, or intimate images or descriptions shared without consent. Do not post gratuitously graphic violence or gore. Do not share illegal material, malware, or instructions for committing a crime. Do not scam anyone.

Do not target people

Do not urge others to flood, contact, or target a person or organization. Do not post private personal information that is not already in the public case record, including addresses, phone numbers, private email, and government ID numbers. Do not name or identify someone whose identity a court has protected, including minors, jurors, and people covered by a sealing or protective order.

Do not state a damaging claim as fact

Do not state, as fact, something the public record does not support when it would damage a real person's reputation. That includes accusing someone of a crime the record does not support.

What happens if you break these

We may remove a comment, hide it while we review a report, or block an account. Impersonation is grounds for a ban. A removed comment may leave a short public note in its place.

These guidelines sit alongside the terms of service. They are not legal advice, and they are not a complete list of every reason a post can be removed.