Next: Motion hearing · Tue, Nov 24
Then: Motion hearing · Wed, Nov 25
Ariana Thacker complained for months about a cigarette smell in her Miami condo. It turned out to be toxic mold, and now she's suing the building.
Updates · 30
The plaintiff asked the court for a protective order, which is a request to block or limit certain questioning or evidence gathering. The court then scheduled the request to be heard on two dates, November 24 and November 25.
The parties will meet with a neutral person (a mediator) on January 7, 2027, to try to settle the case without a trial. This is important because settlement talks can change the whole case.
The defense asked the court to make the plaintiff go through a brain/thinking test (a neuropsychological evaluation). This could be a big deal because it may produce new evidence about the plaintiff's injuries.
The defense side asked the court to make the plaintiff (the person suing) finish a required medical exam with the defense's doctor, Jerome Siegel. This is important because it could affect what medical evidence the case uses.
A judge signed an order that requires a doctor named Ross E. Devere to give brain-test data and test materials directly to the other side's expert, Michael Herkov. This matters because it settles a fight over who gets to see important testing information.
Someone is asking the judge to decide how much a doctor should be paid for answering questions before trial. This matters because it settles a disagreement about the cost of getting the doctor's testimony.
The other side has told the court they are okay with certain people being ordered to share information or documents. This means that part of the case can move forward without a fight.
A scheduled court event was cancelled, so nothing will happen on that date.
The defendant says they will have a doctor examine the plaintiff. Court rules allow this in certain injury cases, so this is a normal step.
Someone has asked the judge for a protective order, which is a legal shield that can limit or stop certain questioning or disclosure of information. This motion is about her businesses, meaning the person filing wants the court to protect details about her businesses from being pried into.
Someone wants to record on video the questioning of a person who represents the defendant company, FirstService Residential Florida, Inc. The notice says the company's representative should be reached through its lawyers. This is usually an important witness because the person speaks for the company.
One side has given formal notice that it plans to question a witness under oath before trial. It is a normal step in gathering information in a lawsuit.
A party sent the other side its first batch of important information and documents about the case.
The judge let the defendant, FirstService Residential, have more time to meet some deadlines before trial.
The judge agreed to an updated plan that sets the timeline for the case, including deadlines for each side.
The judge set a new jury trial date of June 7, 2027, with mediation required beforehand. This is the latest schedule for trial.
The defendants filed updated answers to the amended complaint, including one amended answer. This is their official response to the changed claims.
The judge let the defendants amend their defenses to name another party who might share some blame. In Florida, a 'Fabre defendant' is someone who may be partly responsible, which can affect how much the current defendants pay.
The judge signed an agreed order about the defendants' request to dismiss the complaint or limit certain medical bills as evidence. This resolved that dispute for now.
The plaintiff objected to being examined by a doctor chosen by the other side. The judge issued a ruling on that objection, which affects how the medical exam will happen.
The judge set a new jury trial date for February 22, 2027, and again required mediation before trial.
The judge signed an order granting the defendants' request to move the trial and related deadlines to later dates. Both sides agreed to this delay.
After the complaint was changed, the defendants filed new answers responding to the amended claims. This keeps the case moving forward.
The judge said yes to changing the complaint. This matters because an amended complaint replaces the original one and can add or change claims.
The plaintiff asked the judge for permission to file an amended complaint, which is a revised version of the original lawsuit.
The judge scheduled a jury trial and required the parties to try mediation (a meeting with a neutral person to see if they can settle) before trial.
The defendants officially responded to the lawsuit and denied the claims. One of them also asked for a jury trial, which means regular people will decide the case instead of just a judge.
The judge gave the defendants (the people being sued) extra time to answer the complaint. This means the case slowed down a bit before the defendants had to officially respond.
This is the original complaint. It is the document where the person suing (the plaintiff) tells the court what happened and what they want. This is how the lawsuit begins, so people following the case should know about it.
Alleged in the plaintiff’s complaint:
Miami-Dade Sheriff seeks forfeiture of $35.3M seized from two bank accounts and $2.47B allegedly transferred to third parties, claiming the funds are contraband linked to money laundering and RICO violations.
Added
Comments
Discussion · 1
It’s hard to believe somebody could have lived for so long with toxic mold right in their own apartment. I feel so bad for Ariana.